Angus at Work
A podcast for the profit-minded cattleman. Brought to you by the Angus Beef Bulletin, we have news and information on health, nutrition, genetics, marketing and management.
Angus at Work
Intentionally Retaining Heifers with Eric Bailey
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
The commentary is nearly everywhere ranchers look: Growing the U.S. cow herd means producers need to retain females. With cattle prices currently riding high, that can be easier said than done.
For those cattlemen looking to retain heifers to replace their culled females, intentionally developing females is paramount. On this episode, Angus Beef Bulletin Editor Shauna Hermel visited with Eric Bailey, state beef nutrition specialist with the University of Missouri, to discuss:
- Bailey's presentation at the "Retain with Intention: Building a Better Missouri Cow Herd" event presented by University of Missouri Extension
- Strategies to develop commercial females effectively
- Marketing opportunities for females
- And more!
Additional Resources:
- Beef Feeding Profitability Tracker
- A Rock-Solid Foundation: Tips to Select Females That Will Pull Their Weight in Your Herd
- Commercial Programs at the American Angus Association
- Subscribe to the Angus Beef Bulletin EXTRA
Have questions or comments? We'd love to hear from you!
Find more information to make Angus work for you in the Angus Beef Bulletin and ABB EXTRA. Make sure you're subscribed! Sign up here to the print Angus Beef Bulletin and the digital Angus Beef Bulletin EXTRA. Have questions or comments? We'd love to hear from you! Contact our team at abbeditorial@angus.org.
Host Lynsey McAnally (00:05):
Angus at Work, a podcast for the profit-minded cattlemen. Brought to you by the Angus Beef Bulletin, we have news and information on health, nutrition, marketing, genetics and management. So let's get to work, shall we?
Shauna Hermel (00:30):
Hello. Welcome to this edition of Angus at Work. I'm Shauna Hermel, editor of the Angus Beef Bulletin, and we're here today talking with Eric Bailey at the University of Missouri. Eric. Welcome to Angus at Work!
Eric Bailey (00:45):
Shauna, thank you for having me today. It's a pleasure to be with you.
Shauna Hermel (00:49):
I got a chance to go down to the University of Missouri Southwest Research and Extension Center to participate in a program that y'all had that was called Retain with Intent. There is so much good information that came out of that day and a half session, I guess, two-day session. But one that really stuck out with me today that I wanted to visit with you here as people are traditionally weaning their calves. You mentioned a topic of kind of a blended background in heifer development program. So I want to talk to you a little bit more about that today, but first let's let our listeners have a chance to get to know you a little bit better. Could you tell us what you do there at the University of Missouri and maybe how you came to be in that position?
Eric Bailey (01:38):
Sure. So I am the state beef nutrition specialist at the University of Missouri and am an associate professor in the Division of Animal Sciences. So I'm a beef cattle nutritionist by training, and I've been here at Mizzou, it'll be 10 years in June of next year. So I'm actually a native of Eastern New Mexico, and I was trained at Kansas State University in beef cattle nutrition. So it's been an interesting journey to Missouri because I definitely come at things from more of a range land environment, native prairie, warm season forages. So coming to the fescue belt and dealing with cool season improved pastures, that was a new challenge for me to learn. But I think there is something meaningful to be learned from cross-pollinating. So a lot of my learning is from west of the hundredth meridian, and here I am east of the hundredth meridian, and it's been a fun journey and I really enjoy it a lot.
Shauna Hermel (02:43):
So now in New Mexico, when you were there, how many acres per cow are we talking here in Missouri? We look at cows per acre, but there in New Mexico, you have a different measurement.
Eric Bailey (02:54):
I'm going to throw a curveball at you. One cow per section per inch of rain per year.
Shauna Hermel (03:00):
Wow.
Eric Bailey (03:01):
So we get about 14 inches of rain a year in the county that I grew up in, and that would mean that we're roughly 50 acres per cow stocking rate.
Shauna Hermel (03:11):
That's hard to imagine that kind of a production system outstanding in the fescue here in Missouri, but it is an environment that a lot of cattle do live in. I'm glad you had a little bit of time at K-State to transition to Missouri.
Eric Bailey (03:29):
Absolutely. Yeah, the humidity. Humidity was a very foreign concept to me growing up in a semi-arid desert. My hometown is over 5,000 feet elevation as well. So even in the summer, we would get cooling at night. So we might be 105 during the day, but it'll get down to into the 60s at night. So this 90 degrees during the day, 80 degrees at night, 70% humidity is just 200% miserable for somebody like me.
Shauna Hermel (04:01):
Well, I hope you're starting to acclimate, right?
Eric Bailey (04:04):
Oh, absolutely.
Shauna Hermel (04:04):
Just acclimate.
Eric Bailey (04:06):
After all this time. It was funny, when I moved to Kansas, people told me that the winter was going to be what I had a hard time with. It was not the winter, it was the humidity in the summer. But yeah, we're totally adjusted to it. And I've got a young family and I've got a taproot the size of a mesquite here in central Missouri. So there's a little bit more New Mexico humor to bring to you also.
Shauna Hermel (04:32):
Wonderful. Well, at least we gave you a football team, right?
Eric Bailey (04:35):
That's right. Well, I don't know. New Mexico has had a couple pretty decent football teams here in the last few years. In fact, I'm wearing my New Mexico Lobos hoodie today because they beat North Dakota State on Saturday night.
Shauna Hermel (04:49):
Oh, they just win half our audience, right?
Eric Bailey (04:52):
I know, right? Exactly. Yeah. Well, with the 12 team college football playoff this year, we've got the non-power conferences, they get an automatic bid. So New Mexico is in the driver's seat to actually go to the college football playoff if they can pull through.
Shauna Hermel (05:09):
Oh, wonderful. Congratulations. Well, let's get back to some of this blended heifer development and backgrounding program. We talked at the conference a little bit about some of the traditional ways that we usually select heifers, and maybe there's a, especially as we go into this time where we're looking at possibly retaining more heifers and having an opportunity to sell some heifers, if not put them back in our own herds, I thought it was a great topic to maybe discuss with our audience. So could you maybe walk through some of what you had mentioned on the selecting by phenotype there at weaning?
Eric Bailey (05:53):
Absolutely. Yeah. So you'll just have to probably shut me up at some point, but this is a topic, honestly, it's very near and dear to my heart, and it comes partially from a drought management strategy. So at home, we never stocked at 50 acres of cow, even though that was kind of what the range land would support if you did the animal unit equivalent math. We were usually stocked like 75 to 100 acres per cow, but we would keep our calves after weaning and then raise them on dormant forages over the winter, let them grow the next spring, and then we would sell a green long yearling to the feedlots the following summer. But that was also done because if we were dry, which was very common, we'd sell those calves at weaning and we'd destock the ranch by a third at minimum.
Shauna Hermel (06:48):
So you wouldn't have to get rid of your cow genetics that way.
Eric Bailey (06:51):
Exactly. That's exactly right. So that was where the idea came from. But when you apply it to a cow-calf operation out east here or in the context of maybe even some of the work that Dr. Rick Funston has done at the University of Nebraska, I think there becomes a really neat story to tell that can improve multiple facets of a farm. So let's talk about heifer development, traditional heifer development. So on average, you're probably turning over about 15% of your cow herd every year, open cows, cull cows, death, cows that just are aged and need to be replaced. So the classical model has been to make selection decisions around the time of weaning. I'm going to pick a small subset of my heifer calves and I'm going to develop them to become my replacement cows. In that model, what you're doing then by making those decisions at weaning is you're locking yourself into those handful of heifer prospects.
Now, I would argue that in a low information environment where you don't know much about her mama, you don't know much about the genetics or even now the genomics, that we would be potentially overlooking some females that might really work well in your system.
Shauna Hermel (08:23):
Never the best ones that end up with or the ones that you think are the best from a phenotypic standpoint that wind up having the best production record in the end.
Eric Bailey (08:35):
Exactly. So you arbitrarily made that decision that those were the best ones at that time point, and I would argue in a pretty low information environment. I like to liken this back to NFL quarterbacks. So Patrick Mahomes was the number 10 draft pick in the 2017 NFL draft, was not the first quarterback selected that draft. Mitch Trubisky was by the Chicago Bears. Mitch Trubisky, I'm not trying to throw strays at Mitch Trubisky, but is he even in the NFL anymore? Whereas Patrick Mahomes is on a hall of fame track. There is a lot of uncertainty around that approach. Further, I think there's a second structural weakness in making phenotypic decisions about replacement females at weaning, and that is we're tied to them at that point. We have to get them developed. We then have invested significant resources in those females to maximize the probability of each of those females attaining pregnancy.
And so then we make significant feed resource investments in those females early on before we know anything about them.
Shauna Hermel (09:44):
Once you narrow down that pool, you can't afford for one to show up open if you -
Eric Bailey (09:48):
Exactly. The handful that inevitably do, because you never get 100% pregnancy, they don't fit anything else. You take them to the sale barn as a small group, an odd size at an odd time of year, and you don't get what they're worth for them. My idea, and this is not a new idea, if I ever have an original thought in my career, I will have had an extremely successful career, but I have not had an original thought yet. Developing to a lower target weight, like what Rick Funston and others have talked about essentially - Is that the
Shauna Hermel (10:22):
Fifty-five percent?
Eric Bailey (10:22):
That's the 55%, right? I probably should step back and talk about 55 versus 65. Let's just clarify that. When I say target weight for heifer development, we're talking about developing heifers to achieve roughly 65% of their mature body weight at the start of the breeding season.
Shauna Hermel (10:42):
Which can be a challenge for some of these Missouri herds with some decent sized cows.
Eric Bailey (10:48):
Yeah. When you get into big cows and limited resource environments, if you're not feeding them a lot, not subsidizing them, I call feed a subsidy to heifers, which might sound a little bit negative, but I don't intend it to be. Others have said, "Well, we can develop to a lower target weight, still get reproductive competency, not affect long-term productivity and save $80 in feed costs per head." So that's where the idea of the 55% target weight has gone. But I'll take that even a step further in that I do a lot of work with stockers and backgrounders and feedlots. I've come from a cow-calf operation and I certainly like low quality forages and cow-calf production, but I see a lot of opportunity in adding value to calves after weaning, even for small operations. That's my charge and what I really am passionate about my extension programming focusing on.
Cow-calf operations don't know what their cost per pound of weight gain is by and large, and that is a number that stocker backgrounder feedlots operations live or die by. If their cost of gains are above what the market's willing to pay for that pound of weight, every pound of weight that they put on those calves, they can't make money. It's a margin-based business. Now -
Shauna Hermel (12:08):
How does that cow-calf operator do that for their calves?
Eric Bailey (12:12):
Yeah, so that's a great question. So it's honestly just keeping track of your costs and knowing what your costs are and understanding what the market will pay for a pound of weight gain. We would call that a value of gain, essentially factoring in our price slide. Because when a calf is sold at 500 pounds (lb.) for $4 per lb., if you keep her to 600 lb., you put another 100 lb. of weight on her, the market's not paying you $4/lb., right? That six weight might sell for $3.50 instead. You have to factor that price slide in to get the value of gain. So my perspective, and this may not be universal for everybody, but this is just what I see repeatedly, is that when you get shiny object syndrome and you've picked out your heifers that you love and that you're going to make future brewed cows for you, you'll spend more money to develop them from a nutritional perspective than you would if you were just backgrounding them trying to make 50, $100 a head profit.
My idea then is to take that 55% target weight, but develop these heifers cost effectively and have more of them so that you have multiple opportunities to market females at a profit. So for example, in Missouri, dry fall, very dry fall. I would not want to have to... We've got a lot of hay in the barn. We had a very wet spring. People are pretty decent shape. I would say hay hasn't gotten ridiculously expensive yet. There really hasn't been a lot of hay moving, being bought or sold, at least at the moment, but there certainly is potential to be. We could end up in a situation where maybe some of the farms didn't put up as much hay. They might need to strategically destock. Well, if you have a big pool of replacement heifer candidates, you could just say, "Well, I'm not going to background any heifers this fall.
I'm just going to keep the core replacements and pursue the 65% strategy with them." In a different year where you've got abundant feed resources, keep a much larger swath of your heifers, but don't try to make them gain two and a half pounds a day to hit that 65% target weight. Put them to gain a 1.5 lb. a day, a heck 1 lb. a day, hit that 55% target weight. If you do that cheap enough, then you can make a decision maybe at a pre-breeding soundness exam, some heifers that don't fit that could be marketed at that point. You could go through there phenotypically at that point and decide, "Well, these heifers have done well in my program. These ones have not. The poor doers, I'm going to market." You could also say, "Well, I'm going to stick a straw of AI of semen in all of them and do an estrosynchronization protocol, timed artificial insemination." Even if you end up with a 50 to 60% conception rate, you've probably made more than enough bred heifers for your operation.
Now what I've done is I've taken my first calf heifer calving season and I've condensed it to just all AIs. In a perfect world, you might even have an excess of AI bred heifers more than what you need for your own cow herd replacements.
Shauna Hermel (15:27):
You might start some expansion.
Eric Bailey (15:28):
Exactly. You might start some expansion. We haven't even talked about putting a cleanup bull on afterwards, right? You could also certainly do natural service and do a really short breeding season if you want to tighten the calving window. You could do a longer breeding season with the natural service if you wanted to have an excess number of bred heifers to potentially sell. Just because they don't fit your calving season doesn't mean they won't fit your neighbor's calving season.
Shauna Hermel (15:53):
That sounds like you save the small pool and you try to get 60 to 70% bred on that AI service and then have another sector or another repeat service and then may or may not wind up with as many heifer replacements as you wanted to. This sounds like a strategy where, I mean, you're bound to get the number of heifers that you want to go back into the herd with a hundred percent pregnant, at least going into after that first term or whenever you do pregnancy check. You can take the ones that are pregnant there. We know there's some chances that they might slip a calf later, but at the same time, that definitely gives you a full house, so to speak, for your replacements.
Eric Bailey (16:43):
I'm going to say something controversial, and this is going to make people cringe, but I like heifers better than steers. I have more outs with a heifer than I do a steer, meaning more opportunities to market her, right? I know steers gain more efficiently and faster and people want to take their high end of their steers and talk at the coffee shop about how much they brought per pound. But heifers, there's so much more flexibility. I think they're overlooked in some respects from a marketing standpoint at least.
Shauna Hermel (17:12):
So can you manage those... If you're managing those heifers in a backgrounding system and somebody commits to doing that, can they put them right out what the steers mean? Do they have to be managed differently?
Eric Bailey (17:26):
No, not necessarily. At least they're in the early development phase. If you want to background your entire calf crop in a cost-effective manner, I think that's one real key distinction to drive between this system and maybe some of the more historical 65% target weight, let's push them fairly hard kind of processes. You don't want to do that on very many because you know that you're probably spending more than what the weight gained is worth, but you're gaining the opportunity for this female to get pregnant and stay in your herd and pay you back over time. But no, I think you could absolutely background your steers and heifers together, do it in a cost-effective manner on a more moderate plane of nutrition. Then if you want to sell the steers after 60 or 90 days, hang onto the heifers longer. If you want to sort on the heifers at that point, I absolutely think that's a viable plan as well.
The thing that we didn't talk about, Shauna, before we get off onto another topic, let's talk about replacement heifers. We often say that the first calf is not the most difficult calf to get out of a cow, it's the second one. What I like about this approach, and basically a very short breeding or calving season for first calf heifers is that if they all calve early, early, early in the calving season, that might mean the difference between them staying in your herd as three or four-year-olds or falling out of the herd because you're giving them potentially an extra extra cycle to achieve pregnancy the subsequent year. The worst thing you could do is have a 60-day breeding season and keep a bred heifer that conceives to pregnancy on day 60 of the breeding season. No, seriously, right? Because she's going to calve 60 days into your calving season.
If you're going to stay on a 365-day calving interval, she has to breed by day 82 afterwards with a 283-day gestation length. She has one cycle to get bred, and we know that the postpartum interval of a beef cow is at minimum six weeks, or at least we think it is. I don't think there's strong evidence to say that it's meaningfully shorter than six weeks. So that means then the heifer that calved on day 60 of your calving season, when bulls are going to be turned out, let's say on day 80, she's only halfway through the best case scenario for her postpartum interval, so she may not cycle until the back half of your breeding season, and then even then she might only have one cycle, one chance to get bred. The probability of her falling out of the herd sooner is greater.
We also know that we don't generally back cows up. They don't breed back sooner in subsequent years. And so if she's late to begin with, she's probably going to continue to be late. She's probably going to fall out of the herd sooner. There's good data that would show that the age at which a beef cow is first diagnosed open in commercial herds is lower than what we think it is.
Shauna Hermel (20:29):
Really?
Eric Bailey (20:29):
Oh yeah. I think I even showed some of that data in my presentation, maybe not in the first one, but in the second one. So that would be the work from the Meat Animal Research Center. It's a publication in 2013 that was published in the Journal of Animal Sciences. I'm not recalling the -
Shauna Hermel (20:46):
That's kind of a steep cliff and how many cows drop out between that second and third year.
Eric Bailey (20:53):
Yeah, because we all think that we're going to get a preg rate of 88 to 92% year after year after year. There's going to be this nice steady decline. But if you start with a hundred bred heifers and you have a 25% fallout rate the first year, it looks like that, and then it levels out.
Shauna Hermel (21:15):
Thinking in terms of two, if you're developing those heifers a little bit slower, but yet getting the heifers that conceive early for that in your heifer breeding program, you would hope that they're more fit for your environment if you would. How do we get them to where we maybe haven't poured the grain to them ahead of that breeding season, but what do we do during that first calf to get them to come back? Because they're still growing and we may not have given them the fuel to grow before they calve the first time. How does that interact? Are they just more adapted in the end?
Eric Bailey (21:59):
Well, that's an excellent question, and I do want to clarify that a little bit because I could totally understand how somebody could hear this and say, "Oh my gosh, this guy's crazy." They're 55% target weight, they're light, they're going to calve light, they're still going to be growing. It's going to be a challenge. What I propose is to refocus my feed investments from prior to breeding to after breeding. If I was going to support a female, I would want to support a bred female who I think is going to stay in my herd longer. I'm going to keep her. I still want to achieve. So our goal is to get bred heifers to calve when they're roughly 85 to 90% of their mature body weight so that they have minimal growth left after calving. They're still going to grow some, but we know that in the priority, the hierarchy of nutrient usage in mammals, not just cattle, maintenance energy requirements are first.
Lactation is 1B, meaning that the cow's going to preserve her own basic brain function, heart beating, lungs, pumping, et cetera. Then she's going to make milk. When she has nutrients left over after that, she's going to use them to grow. She has nutrients left over after that, she's going to start putting down some fat. Then if she has some nutrients left over that, then they're going to go to the reproductive system. It stinks, but the reproductive function, the estrus cycle is near the bottom of the hierarchy of nutrient usage in the body.
Shauna Hermel (23:33):
That's survival, right? It's survival of the individual, not necessarily survival of the embryo.
Eric Bailey (23:40):
But that's the piece of this that also makes it challenging for us. So Jordan Thomas and I did a study down there at the Southwest Research Center here recently that we're in the process of publishing where we attempted to do this low target weight heifer development program on fescue, but then we thought, okay, so we've probably got these heifers behind. Once they calve, we're going to start feeding them. So we though, well, let's see what that does in terms of ovarian function, reproductive performance. It was a relatively small data set because it was a self-funded pilot study, but we made heavier calves and that's it.
Shauna Hermel (24:17):
Really?
Eric Bailey (24:17):
So presumably, and if you put this with the work that Dave Lalman is doing at Oklahoma State, we have cattle today that have the genetic potential to make milk far beyond what our environment can provide nutrients for. Our hypothesis now, we did not milk these calves or these cows. We only have differences in body weight between the groups that we did and did not supplement after calving, is that the cows milked more. They made heavier calves. It didn't support reproductive function. It didn't support growth in the cow. It just supported milk. I think that's maybe something that we have selected for in a lot of our higher end commercial cows, and we've gotten disconnected from maybe what the environment will support for some of these cows. That becomes a challenge. I don't want to try to feed the second calf into that cow once she's calved with the first one.
I need to get her where she needs to be before she calves, because at the point of calving, my goal is just to maintain body condition as best I can, not have a big steep decline in plane of nutrition and body condition score that would extend that postpartum interval and push her back to conceiving later in the breeding season. So any of my nutritional investment needs to be done before that first calf hits the ground. I want to make that as a key point.
Shauna Hermel (25:44):
So maybe let's talk a little bit, and I know at Mount Vernon, you talked a little bit about some different options as far as feeding strategies for that backgrounding program, and maybe it sounds like we need to look for a diet that they're going to be on during backgrounding that gets us to where we want to be for breeding. Then what do we look at from breeding to calving?
Eric Bailey (26:09):
So I always like to calibrate. This is a very imperfect scenario. No two farms are the same. No two environments are the same. No two forage resources are the same. So I can make these grandiose prescriptions from my office in the Ivory Tower here at the University of Missouri in Columbia, and they may be completely irrelevant in Nixon, Missouri, a farm outside of Nixon, Missouri, and I just picked a town randomly. But okay, if we take these calves and we put them in a pen with a bale of fescue hay that you cut, what are they going to gain? What's a reasonable expectation? No supplement, no nothing. What's a reasonable expectation? Half a pound a day, I think is probably about where I would land at one-third to .5 lb. I couldn't see them gaining 1 lb. a day because the energy in the forage is going to be lacking and protein will be as well, but energy's probably going to be grossly lacking.
Now, on the other hand, if I take them into a dry lot with a total mixed ration that's based upon corn silage and I want to be very precise with my feeding, I could get them to gain 2.5 lb. a day with pretty minimal effort. So those are kind of the two extremes. I know that not every farm's going to have a mixer wagon and corn acreage to cut silage off of and all of that. To me, it's about calibrating and finding the happy medium between unlimited resource and severely restricted resources. What I generally will tell people is that if you're going to be putting them out with free choice access to hay and you're going to provide a grain supplement that you want to provide somewhere in the neighborhood of three to 5 lb. of a relatively nutrient dense grain supplement, it's got to be a minimum of 14% crude protein, if not maybe even a little higher than that, depending on what the crude protein content in the fescue is.
But then from an energy perspective, I like to use corn and distiller's grains because those are the most nutrient dense, calorie dense feeds out there. A lot of the commodity feed products, they're blends of multiple ingredients like corn and distillers and soybean holes and gluten pellets, maybe wheat midlings, depending on where you're at. Those are all fine options as well. It just depends on how many pounds of feed do I want to carry in buckets every day, because a lot of the decision making that I see on smaller operations comes down to how many buckets can I fit on a side-by-side? What do I have bunks for? I'm not belittling that decision process because why would I spend $6,000 on a TAS trip hopper cake box to put on a pickup if I'm going to feed 20 head? I think that if people took this away, 1% of the heifer's body weight in supplement per day, and it's at least 14% crude protein in the fescue world, if they've got access to free choice hay from there, that's going to go a long way.
I'm pretty confident that most cattle of any kind of genetic merit whatsoever will have no problem hitting the 1.5 lb./day target. Now, I want to backtrack right quick. Why am I focusing on 1.5 lb. day? It's because to get to somewhere in that 55 to 65% target weight range, if I take a 500 lb. heifer out of a 1,300 lb. cow, she needs to weigh somewhere in the neighborhood of 750 lb. to 800 lb. by the time she's breeding. I have about seven months between weaning and breeding generally, and so I've got 200 days to gain 300 lb.. If people will use that, 300 divided by 200 is 1.5. That's my target average daily gain.
Shauna Hermel (30:00):
Getting for calculating that, if I don't have a scale to take an individual weight, what would you recommend for getting an idea of, sounds like we need to know what our cows are weighing so we know what our mature weight is, and then maybe what those weaned calves are weighing so that we can estimate what 85% of that is for -
Eric Bailey (30:25):
Sale tickets for cull cows, that's probably the easiest, least friction way of getting some estimate of what your cows might weigh. You also just got to factor in the body condition score. So in general, and it's a little more precise than this, but in general, in modern beef cows, a body condition score is worth about 100 lb. of weight. It's like 96, but I'm not going to split hairs in this media on that. So if you take a bag of bones to the sale barn and she's body condition score four and she weighs 1,200 lb., then at a body condition score five, your cows are 1,300 lb.. Following me on that one? Conversely, if you do market some calves near to weaning, you'll have an idea of what they weigh. So steers are probably going to weigh, what, 30 to 40 lb. more than a heifer might at similar age.
So you could even use that based upon your steer weights at auction as well. Certainly there may be some shrink things to think about as well there because they're going to shrink when they go to auction. So you need to factor that in as well. But we don't have to have a scale. We don't have to weigh them once a week. We don't have to over complicate it. I think that those rules of thumb and principles are broad enough that they can be applied even in a low information environment like a small farm that lacks the basic facilities or infrastructure to weigh cattle regularly.
Shauna Hermel (31:55):
So if we have that, if we're using those sale tickets for our cows, we ship some calves out of the group, maybe we ship the steers and so we have the steermate weights to those heifers and can average 30 to 40 lb. below that for a weaning weight. Now we've got the parameters to say, okay, if I want them 55 and 55% is what you would use for calculating that, then are there resources that we can use to help us establish a feed ration if we want to from that? Does University of Missouri have any of those resources?
Eric Bailey (32:35):
Yeah, so we would have field specialists across the state. So if you reach out to your local extension office, if you want to have a human help you guide you through that process. Now we don't have specific calculators like other universities do. Oklahoma State has a really good calculator. Iowa State has the brands program. So other institutions, there are free ration balancing programs online if you want to tinker with a custom mix. A lot of the feed companies that are blending feed as well also will be able to guide you with some of that as well. I think it's also relevant to point out in this case, knowing what your feed is going to cost is going to be a substantial factor on your cost of gain because we talked about cost of gain, cost per pound of weight gain, but if your feed costs, let's say, I'm going to pick a silly number, nobody's charging this for feed, but if your feed's $0.40/lb., $800 a ton, and it takes 5 lb. of feed for every additional pound of weight gained, that's $2 per lb. of weight gain just in feed.
That's not practical. That's not going to pencil for heifer development if you're thinking about it from a backgrounder's perspective. Your feed cost becomes an important criteria in this as well. Also, how much of that feed you offer becomes an important factor because the more expensive it is for cost to gain to make sense, it's got to be, I would say your feed cost of gain needs to be below $1.00 per lb. because you're going to have other costs incurred in that. For me, when I look at the value of gain in the 500 to 800 lb. range, it's fairly uncommon to see it be above $2 a lb. once you factor in the price slide, meaning that the market's not willing to pay you in general more than about $2 per lb. of weight gain, at least into the current market environment.
Shauna Hermel (34:29):
That would be to sell them toward a feedlot or somebody to feed toward the end, but not so much for bred heifer or a...
Eric Bailey (34:39):
Exactly. Yeah. I'm trying to think about it as a background or at least early in the developmental phase. I'm not trying to think about a 5,000 plus dollar bred heifer at this point. I'm thinking about a seven weight that I'm going to sell as a yearling to a feedlot.
Shauna Hermel (34:56):
Exactly.
Eric Bailey (34:56):
And that's where it's a little bit of a mentality shift from maybe the way that other folks are currently thinking about heifer development. But I do think there is some real potential for... I mean the added revenue that you can generate, if you can get to a breeding soundness exam and you've generated let's say 200 lb. of weight in these heifers and the difference between your value of gain and your cost of gain is, let's say your cost of gain is $1.20, your value of gain is $2. That's $0.80 per lb. on 200 lb. There's $160 of profit in those animals right there. If you just said, "I'm not going to breed any of them, I'm just going to take them to the sale barn and be done with them." Whereas think about heifer development, if it's 200 lb. of weight gained and I spent, let's say $200 in feed at that point, that'd be pretty expensive feed, but then I have $400 invested in those heifers.
Some of it's a mindset shift because if I'm thinking about profit versus costs and my costs are real high, then heifer development becomes an expense. If I'm backgrounding heifers, some of which I really like and think would make good cows, and then I shuttle them into my cow, my reproductive management system, is heifer development to cost at that point or is it just simply another enterprise that I'm potentially making money off of? Especially in this environment here right now where we, I think from a beef industry perspective, have a desire to expand the cow herd. Now maybe the microeconomic climate is not necessarily conducive for that because of drought or fuel or whatever reason, we could spend a whole different, that could be a whole nother podcast.
Shauna Hermel (36:45):
There's so many.
Eric Bailey (36:46):
There are so many. There really are, honestly. You're exactly right. I think there's something there though. I think there's something there for folks to think about keeping those heifers longer and developing a more than... So if you've got a hundred cows, let me just, I want to break this down brass tacks. If you've got a hundred cows and you need to replace 15 of them every year, the normal farm might keep 20 replacement heifers selected at weaning. Develop them to 65% of their mature body weight, hope for an 80% conception rate so that you get 16 bred heifers and boom, your cows are replaced and then you end up with four open heifers that don't really fit anything that you've spent a lot of money on and you lose money on when you take them to the sale barn because you developed them, their cost of gain was higher than their value of gain.
I'm proposing that 100 cow herd, let's say you have a 90% conception rate or 90% weaning rate. Let me say weaning rate. So you've got 90 calves weaned, half of them are steers, half of them are heifers, you've got 45 heifers. There's probably a handful of heifers that don't need to become replacement heifers under no stretch of the imagination, age, previous disease challenge, blemish of some kind.
Shauna Hermel (38:00):
Some might be too light there to really even get to
Eric Bailey (38:04):
A place where you want them. But don't sell them at that point, just background them and put a little more value on them. But know that of the 45, there really might actually be 40 potential heifers that I want to breed. Then that 40 could be winnowed down at any time in the development phase or at the pre-breeding exam or when it's time to start an estrus synchronization protocol or you go all the way with them and then you end up with a surplus of bred heifers and create another enterprise to sell.
Shauna Hermel (38:35):
You bet. You bet. It definitely makes for rather than, like you say, kind of a cost corn hog, so to speak, to being, like you say, putting in some of the genetics that are maybe going to be more reproductive on your environment anyway and get them started into the program without spreading that development cost over more heifers rather than the few certain ones that you handpicked and may or may not be the best ones for you to keep.
Eric Bailey (39:07):
Now, I'm going to talk out of both sides of my mouth now because with the advent of modern tools like genetic testing, you can learn a heck of a lot about what's under the hood of your heifers. Maybe you've done genomic testing on your calf crop already and you know which heifers that you want to keep based upon those tests. I'm not saying that process is wrong. Those heifers probably, if you're going to do that, they need to be selected and screened out and then developed to that 65% target weight just so that you're maximizing the probability that they do achieve pregnancy. But you can still do that without just unlimited feed subsidy to them. You can still do that in a cost-effective manner if you keep track of your expenses and if you try to make sure that your cost of gain is somewhat in line with industry standards.
Today in Missouri, a backgrounder is going to be putting a pound of weight on a 500 lb. steer heifer for somewhere in the neighborhood of 90 cents to $1.30 a pound. Now that's a pretty wide range, so that factors in death loss and medicine and a lot of things. There's a lot of stuff that goes into that, but if every pound of weight's costing you $2 plus in the 65% target weight, there's probably an opportunity to cut some costs because nutrition is 70% of heifer development costs in general as a rule of thumb. That's the low hanging fruit. That's the big lever that you can change if you need to.
Shauna Hermel (40:42):
Those cow costs, back when I started my career, we talked about a dollar a day for a cow and it's quite much more expensive now.
Eric Bailey (40:53):
I think you could make a credible argument that it's $4 a cow a day.
Shauna Hermel (40:57):
Yes.
Eric Bailey (40:58):
If you look at MU extension cow-calf budgets, they're getting to be 12, 13, $1,400 annual cow costs. Now they've got a lot of non-cash costs factored in, but I think their annual operating costs, which don't have interest or depreciation in them are 1,050 this year. So that's the easy $3 a day.
Shauna Hermel (41:22):
Now, one of the things that you had thrown caution out for was putting calves out on corn stalks where here we're seeing a lot of combines in the field and corn stubble and bean stubble out there. If you've got an electric fence, that might be some pretty good cow feed. Kind of go through why you said for calves that might not be the best.
Eric Bailey (41:44):
Well, it's an energy limitation. The beef cow is the best way to market low quality forages on the planet. There's nothing else that can maintain their body weight quite as effectively as a mature beef cow on a forage that is less than 50% total digestible nutrients. That's our proxy for energy. Calves, when we're talking, all this stuff we're talking, Shauna, if we go nerdy for 30 seconds, what I'm really trying to push folks to get is a diet in front of beef calves that's somewhere in the neighborhood of 60 to 65% TDN. Now, it might seem like 50 and 60 are not all that far apart from one another, but they're pretty good ways. Corn silage is 72% TDN, just to give you kind of some frame of reference. Corn grain is 90.
Shauna Hermel (42:31):
Those fescue bales would be more in 50.
Eric Bailey (42:35):
Low $50s. The low $50s. Yeah. Corn stocks might be just below $50, fescue bales might be just above $50. My whole point, feed your good feed to your growing animals because they're going to convert that to pounds of gain efficiently. The cows that are already on your place, you're not trying to put weight on them, you're just trying to keep them alive, maintain their body condition. Corn stocks are a cheap feed resource that work great for mature cows. Your lower quality feeds goes to your mature cows with your low nutrient requirements. Your higher quality feed goes to your growing animals that are going to be productive for you in terms of paying you back weight gain or otherwise. It's not that I'm opposed to turning calves out on corn stocks per se, it's just that I don't think that they're going to gain much weight without a significant amount of feed supplementation.
At that point, are we better off allocating some good hay and less grain to those calves and then putting the cows out on the stocks with maybe a protein tub or some kind of protein supplement, right? It's about matching the feed resources with the nutrient requirements of the various classes of cattle on your farm.
Shauna Hermel (43:44):
I think we could come back and do a whole other podcast on feeding the heifer from the time we breed her until she calves and then what to do with her from calving to get her rebred. So maybe we can invite you back and have you visit with us a little bit about that. But definitely thank you for joining us today and talking about a little bit about a new approach to, maybe not a new approach, a alternative approach for developing heifers and putting potential replacements back into the herd. Is there anything that you want to finish up with to put a cap on it?
Eric Bailey (44:24):
I would say, and this is out of scope for me, but I'm just going to go there anyway. If you can identify heifers that are productive in a limited resource environment, it seems to me like that's the kind of cow I would want to keep versus the heifer who has been subsidized with unlimited corn silage and total mixed rations that gets turned out to be a mama cow in the back 40 on rank fescue. We don't know how productive she's going to be in that environment, but a heifer who has had to, I don't want to say struggle, but had to hustle a little bit and is productive in a forage environment, there's probably some value in knowing who those are. I think there's labs that are working on it right now, like Dr. Lalman at Oklahoma State. I really appreciate, I think he does really thoughtful work in trying to identify animals that are efficient with forages, not just concentrates like what a lot of our industry has done.
Shauna Hermel (45:20):
You bet. He's done some wonderful work there and some of it at Mizzou.
Eric Bailey (45:25):
Absolutely. That's right.
Shauna Hermel (45:26):
Well, thank you so much. One of the things we try to ramp up with is coming up with asking you for maybe one of the big positives professionally or in your personal life happening right now, focusing on the good.
Eric Bailey (45:40):
That's a good question. I have three lovely children, one 12, one three, and one two.
Shauna Hermel (45:50):
Wow, you got your hands full.
Eric Bailey (45:52):
My two younger ones are both boys, so you can imagine how loud and raucous my house is at most times. But just seeing them develop, they've gone from basically being immobile, little hungry, hungry hippos to they're riding bikes now and talking back to me and we're playing baseball. It's amazing, what do they say? The days are long and the years are short. I'm just trying to sort of wrap my arms around that and cherish that right now. That's the good that's going on.
Shauna Hermel (46:28):
Well, that's wonderful. It sounds like your life is about to get busy with some school activities and extracurriculars.
Eric Bailey (46:35):
We went to volleyball three nights last week. Wow.
Shauna Hermel (46:39):
Well, thank you very much. Now at the meeting, you had mentioned that there might be some more Retain with Intent sessions that are coming down the pike. Is that a potential or have we followed up with that?
Eric Bailey (46:53):
Yeah, so I just want to clarify the Retain with Intention heifer development program that we've put on, that is a collaboration amongst myself, Dr. Jamie Corder, Dr. Jordan Thomas, and Wesley Tucker with MU Extension. Dr. Corder is actually our state beef geneticist and the ringleader of this deal. So I'm on this podcast getting some attention for her program today rather than promoting anything necessarily that's mine. So I just want to clarify that Dr. Corder's the mastermind. We have met and we're planning to do another one, at minimum one in the wintertime, and we'd like to do more of them. Essentially what they are is they're day and a half programs where we look at nutrition, reproductive technologies, genetics, genomics, economics, and then we try to do that in not just the standard classroom PowerPoint lecture environment. We're trying to build activities in and getting people to engage with each other in addition to the instructors.
We know about the cattle cycle, we know how it's gone missing. We know that the last time we had a rapid expansion of the cow herd, everybody made heifers and then they depreciated significantly in a relatively short amount of time. People are kind of gun shy. That's why we call it retain with intention. We want to retain better heifers with intention and do it in a way that's going to benefit the farm in the long run.
Shauna Hermel (48:22):
Well, the program sure did a great job of, I mean, walking through some, I guess you'd call them wet labs, going out and looking at heifers and doing a keep/cull exercise, doing the pelvic exams and some reproductive exercises as well and choosing which one of those heifers or which sets of those heifers can be more profitable for someone down the long haul and maybe have some more of those options like we talked about with this program.
Eric Bailey (48:54):
We'd love to hear from you all too. If there's a particular location or group of folks that would love for us to come do it in your area, please don't hesitate to reach out. I think we've done one in Columbia, we've done one in Mount Vernon, Missouri, but we're wide open. We've got content and will travel.
Shauna Hermel (49:14):
Excellent. Well thank you, Dr. Bailey, for joining us today and we look forward to ... I reckon there'll be two or three items come out of this that we can share through Angus at Work and hopefully a lot more than that through the Bulletin. So thank you!
Eric Bailey (49:29):
Awesome.
Host Lynsey McAnally (49:35):
Listeners, for more information on making Angus work for you, check out the Angus Beef Bulletin and the Angus Beef Bulletin EXTRA. You can subscribe to both publications in the show notes. If you have questions or comments, let us know at abbeditorial@angus.org, and we would appreciate it if you would leave us a review on Apple Podcast and share this episode with any other profit-minded cattleman. Thanks for listening. This has been Angus at Work!